For nearly fifty years, the pro-life movement had the advantage of a single, clarifying obstacle. Roe v. Wade was the elephant in the room. It prevented states from passing any meaningful legislation to protect unborn children, and in doing so it gave the movement one target, one strategy, and one measure of success. Everything pointed toward the day the decision would fall.
Dobbs did not make abortion illegal. It did not extend a single protection to a single unborn child.
That day came, and it did not do what most pro-life Americans assume it did. Dobbs did not make abortion illegal. It did not extend a single protection to a single unborn child. What it did was remove a barrier — it pressed a reset button back to 1973 and returned the question to the states. One monolithic issue became fifty separate ones, and the strategy that had been built for the first was suddenly the wrong instrument for the second.
The movement has been slow to recognize this. There are more abortions in the United States now than there were before Dobbs. Continuing to strategize the way the movement did under Roe is not merely inefficient; it is fruitless. What the moment requires is a pivot.
Losing on Friendly Ground
The clearest evidence that something has gone wrong is where the losses are occurring. Abortion has been written into the state constitutions of Ohio, Missouri, Montana, and Kentucky — states no one would describe as hostile terrain. Florida was spared only because its ballot measures require a sixty percent threshold; a simple majority of Floridians voted to enshrine abortion as a fundamental right.
There is an uncomfortable implication in this. If a state has legal abortion today, it is because the people of that state want it. That is a sobering fact, but it is also an opening. Public opinion is not a fixed feature of the landscape. It can be persuaded, and persuasion is something the pro-life movement has historically been good at — when it remembers to do it.
The other side has been better at it lately. Abortion advocates rarely discuss the issue honestly, and their linguistic strategy is disciplined: abortion is health care, abortion is normal, abortion is a right. They are also tactically shrewd. In several states, abortion initiatives were placed on the ballot alongside other left-leaning measures — in one case, marijuana legalization — specifically to drive sympathetic voters to the polls.
Above all, they campaign on fear. Voters were told that without a constitutional right to abortion, a woman with an ectopic pregnancy would die untreated, or that a woman miscarrying would be left to develop sepsis because no physician would deliver her dead child. The claim is testable, and it fails the test. Years after Dobbs, no physician in any state where abortion is illegal has been successfully prosecuted for treating an ectopic pregnancy. No statute anywhere denies a woman emergency medical care.
But the accuracy of the claim is not the point. The fear works, and it does not only work on the other side’s voters. It works on marginal pro-life voters, on Christians who oppose abortion but recoil at the thought of women being harmed. Any strategy that ignores this is a strategy that loses. Prudence in how the movement advances its legislation is not a compromise of principle; it is a condition of principle succeeding.
The Work Begins in the Church
No state, city, or nation is holier than its churches. If people cannot be helped to understand what an unborn child is and what abortion does to that child, no legislative victory will hold. A great many Christians are sentimentally pro-life — they feel the wrongness of abortion — but are not grounded in it philosophically or biblically. Sentiment does not survive a well-funded fear campaign. Conviction does.
Sentiment does not survive a well-funded fear campaign. Conviction does.
This work has to start in the church, because it will not start anywhere else. But the way the movement has approached pastors needs to change. For decades the message to clergy was essentially an accusation: your silence is killing children, and you have blood on your hands. Whatever its rhetorical force, it has not worked, and it misjudges the men it is aimed at.
Clergy in the West are the most messaged-at group of pastors in human history. Every reel, every channel, every feed features a subject-matter expert explaining to their congregations that the pastor has it wrong. The pastor, meanwhile, is expected to preach at a high level every Sunday, to be a moral philosopher capable of assessing every film and song and headline, to be a competent counselor, and — as the occasion demands — a biologist, a geologist, and an astrophysicist. Handing such a man one more item for his to-do list is not a strategy.
The deeper problem is formation. Many pastors attended a Christian high school where abortion was never discussed, went on to a Christian college where it was never discussed, and then to a seminary where bioethics went unmentioned. They arrive in congregations where people ask why they do not preach on abortion, and they have no answer — not because they are indifferent, but because no one ever taught them. They have also spent fifty years being told by the culture to stay in their lane: no uterus, no opinion.
Conditions were more favorable a generation ago, and even then the churches were largely silent. The movement had an unambiguously pro-life president in Ronald Reagan. It had pro-life advocates in both parties — Jesse Jackson, Dick Gephardt, Al Gore; Joe Biden once co-sponsored a human life amendment. The Catholic bishops spoke forcefully, and the Moral Majority organized in the pews. None of those tailwinds exist today. If clergy were underequipped then, the deficit now is far worse — and it will not be closed by guilt. It will be closed by training pastors to do what seminary should have done: make the scientific, moral, and biblical case for life from the pulpit.
The Trouble with “Equal Protection”
The most consequential strategic argument inside the movement concerns so-called equal protection bills — legislation that would prosecute women who obtain abortions as murderers. Such bills have been defeated in Tennessee and are pending elsewhere, and candidates running on the position have lost primaries in significant numbers. Their political viability is doubtful. The more important question is whether, if enacted, they would be good.
The term invites an obvious question: who, exactly, is being protected? The job of the pro-life movement is to rescue as many children as humanly possible from abortion. Measured against that standard, these bills would not protect all children, and they would place at grave risk children who can currently be saved.
Begin with enforcement. Mifepristone and misoprostol have uses beyond abortion and cannot be eliminated from circulation. Both metabolize so quickly that within hours they are effectively undetectable; the handful of studies that have identified them required extraordinarily expensive, precisely calibrated equipment and highly skilled technicians. Those who supply the drugs know this and coach their clients accordingly: if the abortion is incomplete, go to an emergency room and report a possible miscarriage. California has gone further, passing AB 240, which strips the prescribing physician, the pharmacy, and the patient from the labels of mailed abortion drugs. There will be no evidence to prosecute.
The logistics are equally unworkable. Enforcing such a law would require investigating miscarriages — an enormous number of which occur naturally every year — and subjecting grieving women who wanted their babies to criminal inquiry. No state will staff a miscarriage police force, and no state should.
The gravest cost, however, falls on children who are presently being saved. Once a surgical abortion begins it is virtually impossible to stop; that child is gone. The chemical abortion protocol, by contrast, has a gap in it. Mifepristone is taken first and misoprostol second, and in that interval a pregnancy center can intervene by flooding the woman’s system with progesterone. The research on abortion pill reversal shows that in 65 to 68 percent of cases, the life of the unborn child is saved. This is precisely why the industry has been working to compress the interval, which was once 24 to 48 hours, down to six or eight.
Now introduce an equal protection statute. Everyone who works at a pregnancy center is a mandated reporter, exactly as a school counselor is. A woman who has taken mifepristone — which by itself will cause an abortion in over 75 percent of cases — has, in the eyes of such a law, already acted with intent. If she regrets it and seeks reversal, she would be walking into a building where the staff are legally obligated to report her. She might save her child and go to prison for the attempt. The likelihood that any woman presents herself under those conditions is essentially zero — and the children who could have been saved will not be.
She might save her child and go to prison for the attempt.
There is a political cost as well. Equal protection advocates have handed the other side a boogeyman, and the coming advertisements write themselves: a sympathetic young woman facing prosecution for seeking what voters have been told is basic health care. Some states are already committed to abortion and some to life, but a great many remain undecided, and those are precisely the states such ads are built for. Should abortion advocates ever assemble thirty-eight states, a federal constitutional amendment would erase fifty years of work in an afternoon. And in any state that has already written abortion rights into its constitution, an equal protection bill is dead on arrival regardless.
Abolition, Premature and Permanent
Underneath the tactical objections lies a substitution. Equal protection advocates promise abolition; what they would actually deliver is criminalization. There is a real difference.
Equal protection advocates promise abolition; what they would actually deliver is criminalization.
A statute is not the whole of the law. Between the text on the page and the protection of a child stands the middle section of legal application — the district attorney who declines to charge, the judge who will not hear the case, the jury that will not convict. A law that cannot survive that passage dies standing up. Australia offers the cautionary case: it had, on paper, precisely the ban abolitionists say they want. It went unenforced for years, and when the political moment arrived it was discarded as a dead letter.
Worse, unenforceable laws breed lawlessness generally. Nearly everyone speeds, and nearly everyone knows why: the odds of being caught are low enough to make the risk worth taking. No one would speed if a state trooper followed them from driveway to parking space. Laws that carry no realistic prospect of enforcement teach citizens that law is theater — and in this case, the people distributing abortion drugs are already making the argument out loud, assuring women that detection is impossible and a claimed miscarriage is indistinguishable from a chemical abortion.
None of this is an argument against the goal. There should come a day when the deliberate killing of an unborn child is treated as any other unjust taking of human life is treated. The question is not whether abolition is right but what the movement leads with, and when. Permanent abolition and premature abolition are not the same project, and pursuing the second forecloses the first.
Where the Effort Belongs
The energy currently spent on unenforceable bills has an obvious better use. It belongs in prosecuting abortionists, in stopping the interstate shipment of abortion drugs, and in securing the right of pro-life states to enforce the laws their citizens have already passed. That last question is bound for the Supreme Court before long, and the principle at stake is straightforward: no state should hold a heckler’s veto over another state’s protections for unborn children.
Once life states and death states are genuinely distinct, the comparison becomes visible to ordinary people — what kind of culture takes root where the young are disposable, and what kind takes root where human beings are protected from conception to natural death. That contrast is the movement’s most persuasive argument, and it cannot be made until the laws are allowed to function.
The final pivot is the hardest, because it is not about legislation at all. Far too many Christians who are ideologically pro-life do nothing. Under Roe, inaction had a certain logic to it — nothing an individual did could overcome a federal constitutional right. That excuse is gone. Everyone can now do something effective, and the movement’s central task is to move a very large number of sympathetic people from inaction into action.
Dr. Marc Newman lays out this case at length in Pivot, which identifies five strategic pivots the movement must make — in language, in education, in how it legislates in pro-life states, in how it works within pro-abortion ones, and in moving ordinary people from inaction to action. It is the most timely strategic treatment of the post-Roe landscape currently available, and it belongs in the hands of anyone serious about the question.
The elephant has left the room. What remains is fifty states, a persuadable public, a church that has never been taught, and a great many children whose lives depend on whether the pro-life movement is willing to work smarter than it has.
Episode Transcript
This transcript was generated from the episode’s YouTube captions and lightly edited for readability: filler words and the mid-show announcements have been removed. It may still contain transcription errors.
Hello friends, welcome to The Case for Life program. So happy you’re with us today. What I want to talk about today is what is going on in the strategies of both the pro-life position and the pro-abortion one. And we’ll be joined in a little bit by Dr. Mark Newman to talk about his new book, Pivot, that gets released today. And I want to encourage you to get this book because he
Lays out a strategy for the pro-life movement in a post Roie Wade world. Very important book. For those of you that may not be familiar with Dr. Mark Newman, he is the author of the book Contenders. He’s been a pro-life speaker and trainer for at least four decades, if not longer. And he’s a guy that speaks regularly at pregnancy center banquetss and training seminars for clergy. I look to him as one of my most consistent friends and colleagues in this fight.
Mark, so good to have you with us.
It’s great to be here.
And before we go any further, tell folks a little bit about your background, just so they know. In other words, go ahead and pridefully brag on yourself.
I’m going to have a second Corinthians moment here. Well, I started out my career ages ago, as you mentioned. I was at the University of California at Irvine. I was the director of speech and debate there. And then I finished out my career recently probably recently. It goes by so fast, doesn’t it? Nearly 10 years ago. I was teaching in the doctoral program at Regent University in Virginia Beach. And my background is I teach speech and debate at the lower division level.
Taught rhetorical theory and criticism. In other words, I study argument on the graduate level. And I got sucked into the pro-life movement really early on in my career. I had an associate pastor at my church, Arthur Ellison, who took a one-year leave of absence to be the executive director of this weird thing called a crisis pregnancy center. So, at the time, I was doing some corporate training while I was at UC Irvine. And he said, “I know you do that. Would you come down and train my people?” I said, “Sure.
What do you do?” And so, he started explaining it to me. Now, now, keep in mind, I’m well educated. I had been going to a Christian church for, you know, well over a decade. I knew nothing about abortion. Nothing at all. And we’re it’s in the second half of the 80s here, probably 86,87 and didn’t know anything. And so I said, “Well, send me some stuff and I’ll put something together for you. I’ll just use the corporate stuff and we’ll retrofit it.” And so he sent it to me and my jaw just hit the floor.
I couldn’t believe it. So I went in and I trained them and I thought, “Well, you know, one and done. I’ll get back to working in glass offices in Irvine.” And God had other ideas. And the next thing I knew, I was training a variety of people at the pregnancy center movement level. And then ended up over at National Right to Life and speaking there. And now I’m training a bunch of folks who are statewide representatives for National Right to Life.
And just things grew out of there. As a matter of fact, you actually came to one of the first ones of those to demonstrate how old not just I am, but how old you are.
Thank you. I remember Greg Cunningham had sent you down.
Yes. You’re welcome. To do to come to one of the pro speaker seminars.
Yep.
Yeah. Ages ago. Ages ago.
Yeah. But that seminar taught me how to structure my comments and how to release my material in a way that would be engaging to my audience and I’m still benefiting from that training I received from you. Well, you’ve got a new book out
And before we You do. It came out actually today. It’s now on Amazon. People can get it. And now you’re holding one up. There it is. It’s called Pivot.
Now, let me ask you something. There’s a television show where there’s a scene where guys are moving a couch up the stairs and that one guy is always yelling pivot. Was that Seinfeld? I can’t remember. But why that title? Tell me why that title.
For years, under Row versus Wade, you know this as well as I do, and most of your listeners know this as well. We had a singular focus. There was Row versus Wade and it was the elephant in the room. It kept states from passing any meaningful legislation to protect the lives of unborn children. So then all of a sudden then do comes along, overturns a row and it shatters our strategy, right? We’ve we no longer are dealing with one monolithic issue.
Now we’re dealing with 50 separate issues in 50 separate states.
So to continue trying to strategize in the way we’ve done in the past would be fruitless. And so we needed to pivot. So in this book, what I basically do is lay out kind of where we are right now, right? The things that have happened since the opposition decision came down, how the abortion industry literally had a meltdown for a little while and then they sort of regrouped and retrenched and now they are moving forward. There are more abortions now than there were before DOBS and there are some strategic reasons for that which we can get into.
And so we set up, you know, this is where we are. And then we talk about five strategic pivots we need to engage in involving language, how we speak about this issue, about education, about how we legislate in pro-life states because we’re not remotely done yet, and how we legislate in and work with proabortion states. And then finally, the fact of the matter is far too many Christian people who would be ideologically pro-life really aren’t doing anything. And so we need to pivot from inaction.
And I think the reason people were inactive was because they didn’t think they really could effectively do anything because of row. Well, row’s gone and now everybody can effectively do something. And so we want to move people from inaction to action. And that is that’s the final pivot in the book. We’ve got examples of all kinds of things that anybody can do.
Now, one thing I think we need to clarify here for our viewers. A lot of people assume wrongly that the overturning of Row and Casey somehow gave unborn children protection. It did not. It did something else. Could you explain to our viewers what it did?
Yeah, what it did was it removed all of the barriers that existed at the state level. So it the best way to think about it is somebody pressed a reset button in 1973 and it allows states now to enact their own protections. In fact I believe it was Kavanaaugh who explicitly said this isn’t going to right make abortion illegal nationally right and they said well no it’s just going to return it to the states and that’s what it did. So the interesting fact is the only reason if you live in a state that has legal abortion, the only reason you have legal abortion is because the people in your state want it.
And that that gives us a tremendous opportunity, right? We can make we can help people to see that they ought not want it if we’re smart. But you know what I want to come back to here is we are losing in deep red states like Montana, Ohio, Kentucky, Missouri, and the list goes on and on. We really lost in Florida and the only reason abortion didn’t get written into the state constitution there was because of a 60% threshold.
Correct. Talk a little bit about where the culture is where even in deep red states we’re seeing abortion get written into the state constitution as a fundamental right. How is that even possible?
Well, it’s because as you know, right, the abortion issue is never talked about honestly by our opponents. So, they use all kinds of linguistic tricks. They start talking about abortion being fundamentally healthcare, right? You’ll hear people talk about abortion being normal. You’ll hear and they were strategically smart. They had in a number of states they combined the initiative on abortion with some other left-leaning initiative to drive those people to the polls. At once in one of the states I believe that it connected with legalized marijuana.
And so obviously you know the people out there wanting to smoke weed you know legally are probably going to be the people who are going to pull the lever on abortion. So our opponents are very very smart. Then they used incredible amounts of fear campaigning. So they started running around telling people, you know, oh, you know, if we don’t have this law here in this state, a woman is going to die from having an ectopic pregnancy because a physician won’t be allowed to treat her or she might misaryry and the physician won’t be allowed to deliver her dead child and she will die from having a septic uterus.
They just really fear-mongered hard. I always tell everybody who asks me about that. And I said, “Tell you what, Dobs has been, the law of the land now for what, two years. And, I want you to tell me, actually longer than that. And I want you to tell me, how many physicians have been successfully prosecuted for treating a woman with an ectopic pregnancy in any of the states where abortion is illegal?” And of course, what you’ll hear is crickets because nobody’s ever been prosecuted for that.
Or show me the statute that actually says women can’t get medical care if they need it. It’s not there. But this does raise an important part that I think your book is going to be strategic in addressing.
We may not like that it’s the truth, but the reality is these scare tactics not only work with the public, they work with marginal pro-life voting blocks as well. And so you’ll get pro-life Christians who are like, “Well, I oppose abortion, but I don’t want women being harmed.” And that means we as pro-lifers have to think about how we’re being prudent in advancing our own legislative strategies.
Absolutely. It’s all got to start I think educationally in the church. We I always tell folks, you know, that there is no state, there is no city, there is no nation that’s holier than its churches. And so yeah, if we can’t get into the church and help people to understand what is the truth about the nature of unborn children and what abortion does to unborn children, we’re lost. Because there are a lot of people who are I they are sentimentally pro-life but they are not grounded philosophically or even biblically in the life issue.
And so that’s got to have to it has to happen in the church because it’s not going to happen any other place first. Now see I do think that if it happens in the church first it can spill over into the wider community but it’s got to start at the church.
Yes. Now, one of the things I know you and I have talked about before, an important distinction here. Prior to the overturning of Roie Wade, the primary message the pro-life movement was giving clergy went something like this. Well, your silence is killing children. You’ve got blood on your hands because you’re not addressing this issue. And you and I both know, and I know this as a former associate pastor, by the way, I’m still licensed. I can marry and bury if needed.
But the reality is that these pastors have a to-do list that is eight billion miles long. They are expected to wear a hundred different hats, all of which impose on them crushing job descriptions. We need to pivot in how we approach clergy in our local churches. Talk about that a little bit.
Absolutely. The current clergy in the west is the most messaged group of clergy in all of human history. Every single Facebook reel, every Tik Tok channel, every YouTube channel has got some subject matter expert out there telling his congregants that the pastors got it all wrong. And then the pastor is expected by his congregation to be the subject matter expert on virtually everything. So when I talk to pastors, I tell them, “Look, I get it, right? You’re supposed to knock it out of the park every Sunday.
You’re supposed to be an ideal communicator. You have to be a deep moral philosopher. You’ve got to be able to look at the moral implications, you know, all across social media, all across mass media, films, music, you know, television, and you got to, you know, determine what all the those worldviews are, and then provide appropriate responses. And then, you got to be a really, really good a counselor, you know, in the office. And, oh, and by the way, you also need to be a biologist, a geologist, and an astrophysicist.
And, right, the list goes on and on. And now here comes Scott Klusendorf and Mark Newman saying, “And by the way, I got one other thing for you.” And a lot of pastors, I think they’re just fatigued. They cannot fatigued. Yeah.
Well, yeah. And also, they’ve been told virtually all of them are men, unless you’re, you know, with the Church of England.
Sorry. You can edit that out later. Virtually
They’re virtually all men. And so, they have been told by the culture for the last 50 years, stay in your lane. If you don’t have a uterus, you don’t get an opinion. Right? So, you’re not supposed to talk about this. It’s a woman’s issue. They say. And so when you combine all of that with the fact that these guys maybe they went to a Christian high school where they never talked about abortion. Then they went on to a Christian college where they never talked about abortion.
And then some of them went on to seminary where surprise they never talked about abortion, bioeththics, any of that kind of stuff. And now suddenly they find themselves in a church maybe in a conservative area and people are coming up to them saying, “Hey, how come you don’t preach about abortion?” Well, they don’t want to look like idiots. By the way, Mark, the problem is even worse today than it was when we got started. You and I are class exhibits here.
We weren’t hearing about abortion. And this was at a time when the pro-life movement had much stronger tailwinds. We had a an undoubtedly pro-life president and Ronald Reagan. We had pro-life advocates in both political parties. We had pro-life Democrats at the time like Jesse Jackson, Dick Gart, Al Gore, Al Gore, even Joe Biden signed and co-sponsored a human life amendment. So, we had representatives in both political parties. The Cath the Catholic bishops were speaking out on this issue quite strong and we had the moral majority organizing people in churches.
None of those things are happening right now really. And so, is it any wonder that we’ve got clergy that aren’t hearing what they need to hear on this topic? And if we just give them another todo list item, that’s a big problem. Hey, we’re going to take a short break. When we come back, let me cue the next question up for you. I’m going to go ahead and go there. But there’s a part in your book where you talk about why these equal protection bills that are being floated are really problematic, and you give an answer that primarily goes like this.
They’re uninforcable. And I want to hear your thinking on that.
Because most people aren’t saying that, they’re saying other things. So I want to hear your unique perspective on that. We’re going to pick that up right after the break. We’ll be right back, folks.
Welcome back, friends. Great to have you with us. We have Dr. Mark Newman with us and he’s got a new book out called Pivot that I want you to get. It’s there at Amazon. It’s probably at other book selling sources, too. But you want to get this if you care about pro-lifers working smarter in a post Roie Wade world. So, Mark, I kind of teased you with a question before the break, and that is you’ve got a section in your book.
You went there. So, I’m going to call it out and say where you said these equal protection bills like the one that recently was defeated in Tennessee, there’s one coming up in South Dakota, and we’re seeing equal protection candidates be defeated in recent primary elections in pretty large numbers. But that’s not the only problem with this movement. What is it that concerns you about these so-called equal protection bills that will prosecute women for murder if they have an abortion?
Well, as you and a number of other people have already very aly pointed out, it’s just never going to happen. But even if it could happen, the question is, would it be good? I find it really interesting that they use the term equal protection. And what I want to respond to is is well, who are you protecting? Right? I’m going to argue that the job of the pro-life movement is to protect as many children from the evil of abortion as is humanly possible.
Right? We want to rescue as many children as possible from abortion. So the question is these guys are saying, “Well, if we pass these laws, then we’ll protect all of the children.” And I’m going to say, not only will you not protect all of the children, you will put children who are currently able to be saved at tremendous risk. And there are a number of reasons for that. Number one, for starters, it’s impossible to get rid of the drugs, right? All right, mythopa pristone and misoprotool both have other uses beyond abortion and so you’re not going to be able to get rid of those drugs are going to be around for a really long time.
Secondly, you’re never going to have the evidence to prosecute anybody because the drugs metabolize so rapidly inside the woman’s body within hours of taking the drugs. Those the drugs are virtually undetectable. There have been a couple of studies and I mean I’ve ran across just a couple of them where they’ve been able to find the drugs either in a woman’s body or in the body of the fetus. But in order to do it, you would need unbelievably expensive equipment that cost a ton of money to calibrate that would that require you know very very skilled technicians to be able to run.
And so it’s virtually impossible. So much so that the people who engage in what I call etail abortion, right? So, I don’t like the term tellahalth because it’s there’s nothing healthy about it.
Yeah.
What these people do is they’ll tell them, look, if you have an incomplete abortion after taking the abortion pill, just go to an emergency room and tell them, I think I’m pregnant, but now I’m bleeding, or I think I’m having a miscarriage, and no one’s going to be able to find out that you took these drugs. So, it’s just not possible to find the drugs because they disappear out of a woman’s system. And then you have states like California passed AB240 where they have now taken all of the identifying features off the label of the drugs when they mail them.
So the doctor is not identified, the pharmacy is not identified, and the patient
Is not identified on the bottle. You’re going to have a very hard time getting any evidence from these folks. And then the problem then becomes we now lose in many regards we lose our ability to target the abortion industry. But here’s the one that I think is the scariest because I know we’ve we have limited time here. Right now at many pregnancy centers, we have the ability, right? The beautiful, if you can call it that, aspect of the abortion pill over surgical abortion is once surgical abortions start, it’s virtually impossible to stop them, right?
That that baby’s gone. In the abortion pill protocol, there’s a gap between taking methopristone and misoprotol. Now, it used to be 24 to 48 hours, and now, you know, they’ve been doing research trying to get it down to six to eight hours. And there’s a strategic reason for that. They don’t want pregnancy centers to intervene. But pregnancy centers can intervene during that gap. And the research shows that 65 to 68% of women who get the abortion pill protocol, a reversal protocol, which is just they flood her system with progesterone.
In 65 to 68% of the cases, they can save the life of that unborn child. Okay. Now, let’s roll this back. We have equal protection laws. A woman takes methopristone. Now mythopristone by itself if you don’t take anything else will cause an abortion in over 75% of cases. Everybody who works at a pregnancy center is a mandated reporter just like a school counselor would be. So if a woman has taken methopristone she has intentionally determined that she’s going to harm her child.
Now now she regrets it. She feels bad about it and she wants the progesterone. But if she comes in and tells them, I’ve taken methopristone, now they would be mandated reporters, and they would have to turn her in. No. Might save her baby and then she’s going to go off to jail. Now, if that is the case, what do you suppose are the odds that that woman will ever present herself at a pregnancy center for abortion pill reversal if she knows that when she does so, she’s probably going to be prosecuted and go to jail?
Minus billion are the odds. Yeah.
Yes. So, these are children who can be saved. They can be saved. But these equal protection laws will make it not possible. So number one, not enforceable. You’re not going to be able to find anybody. You’re not going to be able to prosecute anybody. It’s by the way, and it’s logistically a nightmare. What are you going to do? Start the miscarriage police? Do you have any idea how many women naturally misaryry every year? And can you imagine the trauma of coming in and being investigated?
You wanted a baby and now you miscarry. And now on top of that, people are going to come in and do this. So it’s logistically impossible. You’re never going to be able to staff it. You’re never going to be able to find the women. You’re never going to be able to successfully prosecute the women. And then beyond that, you’re going to stop APR. And then the worst part about this is the equal protection folks, they are creating a boogeyman that I wouldn’t be surprised at all if Democratic groups are shoveling money at these folks because they want to prop them up, right?
Just like they had an article in the New York Times, right? Making them look like the boogeyman. And so we’ve got a number of states that are already allin on abortion. We’ve got a number of states that are all in for life. And then we’ve got a lot of mushy middle states that haven’t made a decision yet. Can you imagine the ads that are going to come out with the beautiful young woman, and I’ve already seen ads like this, who’s being currently prosecuted now because she was just trying to get fundamental health care, which is her right.
Right. That’s how they’re going to pitch it.
Yeah. Well, the minute the other side gets 38 states, they are going to push to pass a constitutional amendment that is going to enshrine row and then every single protection we have been working for over 50 years to put in place will be immediately wiped away. And by the way, an equal protection bill is dead on arrival in a state that has written abortion rights into its state constitution. And you know, when I talk to these people, they say to me, “Hey, you know, we’re we should be able to do this in red states if pro-lifers would just join with us.” Well, pro-lifers and abolitionists couldn’t join together to stop these bills from being written into these red states like Ohio, Missouri, and other places.
And so, it’s just pure fantasy. They think our strength is vastly greater than it is. But I’m bothered by something else, Mark, and I’m curious about your thoughts on this. I think these people are engaging in a slight a slight of hand. And here’s how. They’re promising abolition, but what they’re really delivering is criminalization. Now, count me among those who wants to see a day when abortion is treated exactly the way any other homicide would be, any other unjust taking of human life.
I get that. But there is a credential issue about what we lead with. But what I’m getting at is you what I see the equal protection people doing and I’m glad you’re talking about this in pivot. What they’re doing is they’re totally ignoring the middle section of the application of law. You can have a statute on the book that does nothing that no juries will convict, no DA will enforce, no judge will you know even allow to come before his court.
Your law dies standing up in that kind of environment. And that’s what we saw in Australia, for example. They had a perfect ban on abortion, one that every abolitionist would love.
And yet the thing was never enforced and then a future legislative time arrived and it got thrown aside as being useless and not applicable. And that’s the danger. So I like the idea of distinguishing permanent abolition from premature abolition.
Well, here’s the thing. So, you’re correct. There are a lot of jurisdictions that won’t enforce the law. We’ve already seen that in many instances here in the United States on all kinds of other laws. But what I explain to people is I say, “Look, have I know you own a Mustang, so I know the answer to this question.” Scott Klusendorf, have you ever broken a speed law in that car? Ever.
The right question would be, have I ever not?
Okay. Well, I ask this to people all the time. Have you ever sped? Everybody says, “Sure. Yeah, absolutely. I have.” Well, would you speed if you knew every morning when you pulled your car out of the garage a state trooper was going to pull up behind you and then follow you around all day long till you park the car in the evening? Well, the answer is obviously no. Well, why not? Well, because I’m going to get caught. That’s correct. So, what happens when people get behind the wheel of a car?
They make a costbenefit analysis. They need to go somewhere. They recognize the odds of being caught are very slim and as a result, they go ahead and speed. Now, every once in a while, they get caught and they feel, “Okay, I’ll go and pay the fine.” you know, and you know, away I’ll go. The fact of the matter is that when you make laws that are uninforcable, you breed lawlessness. And so, it’s not just that that it won’t be enforced at the at certain jurisdictional levels.
I mean, you can pass laws all you want in Texas, right? And then you’d have guys in Austin letting people go left and right or never prosecuting to begin with. But beyond that, you’ve got the people supplying the abortion drugs telling their clients. You’re not going to get caught because you can’t it can’t be detected. So, just don’t worry about it. Tell people you’re having a natural miscarriage. They can’t tell the difference. So, yeah, you can’t pass uninforceable laws. And it also takes our eye off the ball.
We should be going after abortionists and we should be stopping the interstate shipment of abortion pills. If we could lock down our pro-life states so that they would they could literally enforce their own law. If the Supreme Court, they’re bound to be getting this case shortly. Would be able to lock them down and say, “Look, you can’t have a heckler’s veto over a state’s pro-life laws.” And once that happens and we solidify life states and death states, I think people are going to be able to see very clearly what kind of culture is bred in a state that emphasizes death for its young and a state which protects the lives of people from the moment of conception until natural death.
Mark, we’ve got about a little over a minute. Where can people find Pivot in addition to Amazon?
Right now it’s at Amazon. We’re working through some issues with Ingram Spark. Right now they messed up on the cover. So until we can get those things justifi you know fixed it’s going to be on Amazon exclusively right now.
And is there any plan for you to go out and teach the pivot material in seminar fashion?
We’ve got the contend for life events that are happening in various places throughout the United States. Go to contend forlife.com and you can see where we’re going to be. There we teach pastors how to make the case for life from the pulpit. We train them how to do what the seminary should have taught them how to do. And the great news is it doesn’t take forever. We do it in about 90 minutes. And then in the evening we teach a pro-life apologetics class to you know are wide to everybody who wants to come.
How to make the scientific moral and biblical case for life. Why abortion ideology puts all human beings at risk and what they can do about it. Well, I’m going to tell you folks that are watching this book gets my strongest endorsement. After you buy my book, you should buy this one. Actually, start with Markx because it’s at the strategic level. I am so glad you wrote this book. I can’t think of a more timely moment to introduce it to the culture.
Thank you for writing it and I hope this book has the influence you want it to have and helps us think clearly about the right strategy moving forward to save the most lives possible because that’s ultimately our goal. Mark, thanks for joining us. God bless you, Scott. Thanks for having me on.
All right, folks. That’s a wrap for today. Look forward to seeing you next time. We’re going to have Mark on again very soon to talk about how Pivot applies to pregnancy resource ministry. We’ll be talking about that with him in a subsequent show. But for today, that’s it. Look forward to seeing you all next time.