Micah Kunkle is one of the brightest pro-life leaders in the country. He is not up and coming; he already is one. He is doing great work defending the unborn in the public square, and he has some very good thoughts on where the movement is.
You may have seen him in the Jubilee debates, including the Surrounded series. He is fearless. He makes a very good case, and he wins.
A Third of My Generation Is Dead
Micah has done about ten Jubilee videos, maybe a few more. In the Surrounded format, he is usually not the lone voice. One person sits in the middle and disagrees with everyone, and Micah is one of the twenty surrounding him. But the format still gives him one-on-one debates.
One of those exchanges went viral. His opponent was waxing eloquent about why society needs abortion and why we should care about the people who are already here, all while assuming the unborn aren’t human. Micah looked at him and said, “A third of my generation is dead.” It was a showstopper.
What the Debates Reveal
The biggest lesson from these exchanges is that a lot of people have not thought through this issue very deeply.
The opponent in that viral exchange was Tim Miller, who has been in politics for a long time. What the cameras don’t show is that he was hesitant to debate abortion at all. He looked around at the Jubilee producers as if to say, “I don’t know if this is my best topic. I don’t know if I should do this.” Here is a man who has been in politics for years, and he did not have an argument on abortion. Yet he still holds pro-choice views.
The same thing shows up among conservatives and Republicans. Being pro-life in the full sense, wanting abortion completely abolished with no exceptions, puts you in the minority even in conservative circles. Plenty of conservatives hold exceptions for rape and incest and do not believe the unborn should be protected from the moment of fertilization. Even in Republican circles, that is unfortunately changing.
Conservative colleagues on other issues say the same kind of thing: “I’m generally pro-life, but I always think there should be exceptions for rape, for fetal anomalies, whatever.” That is different from a politician who wants to protect all children but simply does not have the votes. These are people committed in principle to the exceptions, not politicians who tolerate an evil they are powerless to stop. That is troubling, and it is why we need more people out there educating the public on what this issue is.
Why Pro-Lifers Need Debate Training
Many young pro-lifers say, “I could never do debates.” They should go forward anyway, and they should get trained.
Debate is one of the instruments of change in a culture. Go back to slavery and look at the Lincoln-Douglas debates. They were part of how slavery got abolished. If you want pro-life laws enacted, debate and convincing people are a huge part of that.
But debates work the other way around too. If you are not ready and trained, and your opponent dog-walks you, you have lost not just that person but the audience as well. That can be very damaging to the movement. So get trained, especially if you plan to do something as public as Jubilee.
It is shocking how many people show up to these debates completely unprepared. They have never debated before. They have only had conversations with friends. They have never done a practice debate. They haven’t prepped the prompts; they just look them over without doing any research. You can tell, when you have done the research yourself, that ten minutes of prep would have given them the point they needed. They didn’t put the work in, and they make the conservative side, or the pro-life side, look foolish.
We have to prepare, because debates are always a minefield. You can lose in one of two ways. You can lose on the argument because you did not prepare well, and you can lose rhetorically.
Take a debate about fourteen years ago at an Episcopal high school outside Philadelphia, in front of the liberal audience you would imagine, against a state representative from Pennsylvania. The research was done. Every argument he was going to make was known in advance, the preparation was there, and it wasn’t close. His arguments were crushed. But he recovered quite well at the end. The pro-life side had the last statement, and when he asked to make a final comment, the moderator said no. So he asked, “Well, can I at least do smoke signals?” It got a big laugh. It did not mean the debate was lost, but it shows how little things can turn an exchange. You have to be prepared for that.
Where Young Men Are Going
Among young conservatives in general, and especially young men, there is a lot of angst about politics, about this country, and about its future. Some of it is justified. But a lot of them take it way too far. They go to extreme people and extreme routes without thinking through the implications of their views or what they are doing.
On the right, that has looked like young men going to people like Nick Fuentes or Tucker Carlson, figures who are more extreme on the right. In the pro-life movement, among young men who are fiercely pro-life, it looks like abolitionism. To their credit, the abolitionists have done a good job of meeting young men where they are and appealing to them in a certain way. That is not necessarily a good thing, but they have done it.
Young women are usually in a totally different place. The polls show young men and young women heading in opposite directions politically, and young conservative women are usually more moderate and less extreme than their male counterparts.
How Equal Protection Advocates Lost Me
That brings us to the whole abolition and equal protection debate, and to an article Micah is publishing called “How Equal Protection Advocates Have Lost Me.”
There are three reasons, and each one comes down to a failure in the conversations surrounding this issue.
Failure One: No Compelling Biblical Case
The first is a failure to present a compelling biblical or theological case.
It helps to separate equal protection from abolitionism for a moment, because some people support equal protection without identifying as abolitionists. From that side, there does not seem to be a single article or argument making the biblical case for why we need equal protection now. On the abolitionist side, the biblical arguments are not very compelling at all.
Take the verse in Romans 3 about doing evil so that good may come. Abolitionists apply it to a politician who does not have every option available. He has this terrible bill or that terrible bill, and one does more evil than the other. But the Romans passage is not talking about lawmakers in that position. It is talking about the person trying to justify evil, doing evil acts because of the good that may come, not someone who would refrain from those acts if he could. Are these bills wrong? Yes, of course. But when you are choosing the lesser of two evils, you choose the lesser of two evils, and you work your way toward God’s perfect justice.
Many of the other verses abolitionists cite talk about doing justice. Everyone agrees with those. But simply citing them almost begs the question, because the question is how you do justice and how you achieve it. They are assuming the very thing they are trying to prove. In fact, abolitionism does less justice than incrementalism.
Craig Ireland makes the point well. The smash-mouth incrementalist gets all he can. He saves all the children he can, then keeps coming back until he gets them all. He is in the position of not being able to end all evil, so he does the best he can to save as many as he can. The abolitionist, or more accurately the immediatist, is in the position of having the power to save some children and refusing to do it. He is willing to sacrifice, say, seventy percent of the children because he cannot get the other thirty percent, and he will be held accountable for that.
Romans 3 is sometimes paired with Isaiah 10, on partiality. But neither passage speaks to someone trying to limit evil or lessen it. They speak about the drivers, the originators, who intend evil and create policies and contexts where the poor are exploited. They do not speak to the person who is powerless to get rid of all the evil and so does the best he can to mitigate it. Those verses do not apply.
Look closely at Isaiah 10. When it talks about those who keep writing oppression, the writers who keep writing oppression, it describes a repeated action. It is talking about lawmakers who repeatedly try to do evil, not lawmakers who repeatedly try to do good, which is what many pro-life lawmakers are trying to do. That verse does not apply to this debate at all.
Failure Three: Not Reading the Cultural Room
The third reason in the article is a failure to show how these bills are practical and prudent. There is a major failure to read the cultural room.
Look around, and unfortunately, pro-lifers are losing almost everywhere. There are wins here and there in different states, but we are losing a whole lot. That means we need to take back ground, and we will not do that by pushing bills our culture considers even more radical. Poll after poll shows people becoming less pro-life. More abortions have been done. Florida, a huge red state, came within a couple of points of enshrining abortion in its constitution. It is hard to see how it is practical or prudent to even enact these bills.
There is cultural work you have to do. And that position is often misconstrued as fear, as though we are afraid to advance anything unpopular or afraid of what pro-aborts might think. It is not fear of pro-aborts. Thirty-six years of debating them publicly has never been frightening. The worry is what these bills do right now to further marginalize the partially pro-life voting blocs we need to advance real legislation, and we desperately need to stop state ballot initiatives from continuing to take root in red states.
Right now we are looking at red state after red state. Montana, Ohio, Kentucky, Missouri, and recently Arizona have written abortion into their state constitutions. Unless God intervenes, it is going to happen again in Idaho and other states, with Virginia coming up in November. We are losing red states to voters who vote abortion into the state constitution.
So here is the question for equal protection advocates. If we can’t even stop red states from voting abortion into their constitutions, what makes us think now is the time to lead with bills that allow women to be prosecuted for murder? Those bills will be used against us. They will be used to tell the public that pro-lifers hate women, want them incarcerated, and want them to die, because pro-lifers won’t give them the medical treatment they need for an ectopic pregnancy.
The concern is not popularity. Being disliked comes with the work. The concern is cultural sustainability. Like it or not, you cannot just pass a statute and expect it to hold up without some measure of cultural foundation for it. You can pretend that is not the case, but think about it even biblically. Josiah was arguably the most righteous king in all of Judah’s history, and he banned child sacrifice by royal decree. Within a generation of his death, child sacrifice roared back. The royal decree banned the practice, but it did not change the hearts and motivations of the people, who remained wicked. So the practice came roaring back.
We can see the same thing in our own day, in countries like Australia. Queensland had a law on the books that every abolitionist would love. It banned all abortion. It made abortion illegal, with no exceptions, everything we want. And yet the statute died standing up, because no one would enforce it. The courts would not enforce it and prosecutors would not bring cases. That is the fear.
This is not opposition to abolition. We are for it. It is not even opposition to prosecuting women for having abortions. Some pro-lifers say we should never prosecute them. We can, and we ought to. But prudence comes into play when we talk about penalties.
They Are Functioning Incrementally
Going forward, these bills are going to keep failing. Most of them are not even getting voted on, and in Louisiana the governor vowed to veto the one there. None of them look viable.
The advocates themselves share some agreement on cultural sustainability. Otherwise, why aren’t they pursuing something federal? Why worry about the states at all? Go for the main one. Go for the federal government and a federal abortion ban. But they realize that is not practical. In other words, they are functioning incrementally. They can’t achieve a federal ban, so they are trying to do it through the states.
The article returns to this point several times. If you were truly an abolitionist, and if you were not “taken by fear,” as they put it, you would pursue a federal abortion ban and abolition all the way. But it is not practical, and it is not going to happen in this cultural moment. That is all incrementalists are arguing. On principle, equal protection advocates should actually agree.
Failure Two: No Answer to History
There is something else worth noticing: the way equal protection advocates tend to misconstrue the incrementalist position. They fail to interact with the argument, and that is the second point in the article. It is a failure to refute the historical examples of social reform.
There is no deep interaction with them. Advocates may make a point here or there, but press them on it and they back away: “Well, actually that wasn’t a great example,” or “Actually, I wouldn’t have agreed with Wilberforce doing that in this case.” They fail to interact deeply with the argument.
In debate, that is called clash. You have your case and they have their case, and when the cases meet, that creates clash. As soon as abolitionists start clashing with someone who knows the arguments, they lose, and their arguments fall apart.
What shows up again and again is an utter ignorance of the history of social reform. In a number of recent hostile interviews, some two-on-one and some one-on-one, the lack of knowledge about how social reform actually happens has been shocking. Whether the subject is Lincoln or Wilberforce or anyone else, there is no understanding of it. That says something about why their case is not rooted in the real world we are forced to live in as Christians, where we aim to limit evil and promote the good as much as we can.
They Have Failed to Make the Case
That is the whole argument of Micah’s piece. Equal protection advocates have failed to provide a case, whether biblical and theological, historical, or practical and prudent in this moment. For those three reasons they have lost him, and he still wants to pursue an incremental approach. It is the only way to win.
Look at the left and at how they have done what they have done. Carl Trueman has written a great book on this, The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self, and it shows that this has been a long time coming. It was slow and incremental. It came through academia and Hollywood and was pushed through other outlets long before any legislation hit any floor. We need to take a page out of their book, because they have been successful.
They have also jumped the gun on transgender issues, and they are now losing people. People are starting to wonder, and to realize, “Actually, this started a long time ago, with Obergefell and with contraception.” They are starting to rethink these things. That is the problem when you jump the gun.
Episode Transcript
This transcript was generated from the episode’s YouTube captions and lightly edited for readability: filler words and the mid-show announcements have been removed. It may still contain transcription errors.
Hello friends, welcome to The Case for Life program. Delighted as always to have you with us today. I get to talk to one of the brightest rising young pro-life leaders in the country. A young man who I think is doing great work defending the unborn in the public square and who one and one who has some very good thoughts on where the movement is. And we’re going to talk about those today. My guest is Micunk. You may have seen him on some of the Jubilee debates, some of the surrounded debates.
He goes in and debates pro-abortionist even when he’s outnumbered. The man is fearless. He makes a very good case. And I’m going to tell you straight up, he kicks butt in these debates. He wins. Micah, great to have you with us.
Thanks for having me, Scott. I’m flattered.
How many Jubilee debates have you done?
Oh jeez. I think we’re coming up here on like around 10 about 10 different videos. If not a little bit over that. Yeah.
And on these you’re largely outnumbered. You’re there the lone guy defending the pro-life view. Have I got that right?
No. It’s usually the way that the surrounded works, which is the series that I’m usually on. It’s usually I’m the one that that’s part of the outnumbering. So it’s the one person that disagrees and then I’m part of the 20 that’s surrounding him. And so but you get to do one-on-one debates yeah, in that format, which is good.
Well, thanks for correcting me on that. I had it backwards, but you’re right. I’ve seen you go one-on-one and there’s one that’s just gone viral of you looking at one of your opponents and he’s waxing eloquent about why society needs abortion. And you just look at him and say, “A third of my generation is dead.” And it kind of just was a showstopper. I mean, the guy was coming at you with all kinds of stuff about how we need abortion. We should care about people who are already here.
He’s totally assuming the unborn aren’t human. And you do a great job engaging him. What have you learned doing these kinds of exchanges? What have you learned about where the culture is in particular?
Well, what I’ve learned is that I don’t think a lot of people have thought through this issue super deeply. The guy you’re referring to is was Tim Miller who’s been in politics for a long time and it just it shocked me that when I go up there to have a 10-minute abortion debate one but the cameras don’t show is that Tim is kind of hesitant to debate abortion when I when I he’s like kind of looking around at the Jubilee producers like hey I don’t know if like this is my best topic I don’t know if I should do this but I’m like you’ve been in politics for years and years now, Tim, and you don’t have like a you don’t even have an argument for me on abortion. But he still holds these pro-choice views.
And so, I think that’s something that I’ve learned. But what I’ve learned is that and then even just talking to the other conservatives and Republicans is that as far as like being pro-life of wanting abortion to be completely abolished and having no exceptions for that you’re in the minority even in conservative circles. There’s plenty of conservative friends that I have that have exceptions for rape, incest that don’t believe, from the moment of fertilization that the unborn should be protected. And so, even in Republican circles, it’s unfortunately somewhat changing.
You know, I have found the same thing with conservative colleagues I’ve worked with on other issues who say to me things like, you know, I’m generally pro-life, but I always think there should be exceptions for rape, for you know, fetal anomalies, whatever. And the interesting thing there is that’s different from a politician who wants to protect all children, but simply doesn’t have the votes for it. These are people in principle committed to these exceptions, not politicians who tolerate an evil they’re powerless to stop.
And that’s always troubled me and it speaks to why we need more people like you that are out there educating the public on what this issue is. Now, you’ve done a lot of debates, but you’ve also done debate training. You’ve been schooled in debate. Why do you think young pro-lifers need to go that route? Because I get a lot of them who say to me, I could never do what you do. I could never do debates. And I always encourage them to go forward anyway, of course.
But what have you learned from that experience of debating that is valuable to upand cominging apologists?
I think debate is super valuable. One, this is how we know that culture changes through debate. It’s one of the instruments of change in culture. You can go back to slavery and you can look at the Lincoln Douglas debates. Famously this is a part of how slavery got abolished. And so if you want pro-life laws to be enacted, then debate and convincing people is a huge part of that. But then debates can also work the other way around for your opponents as well.
And so if you’re not ready and trained to have conversations and to have debates and your opponent essentially like dog walks you in the conversation or the debate, you’ve now lost not just that person but the audience as well. And that can be super damaging to the movement. And so, you need to be trained in debate, if you’re especially if you’re planning on doing, something very public like Jubilee. Scott, it’s it shocks me how many people show up to these debates completely unprepared.
They’ve never done debate before. They’ve only had like conversations with friends. They’ve never done any sort of practice debates. They haven’t even prepped the prompts. They just like look the prompts over, but they don’t actually do any research into them. And how I know this is because I actually put research and prep work into it. And I’m sitting there thinking, okay, if you had done even just 10 minutes of prep, you would have known this. So why aren’t you bringing it up?
And it’s because they didn’t put any prep work into it. And they essentially make the conservative side or if it’s a pro-life debate, they can make the pro-life side look foolish.
Yeah, we have to prepare. And I’ve told aspiring apologists who want to do debates are always a minefield because you can lose one of two ways. You can lose on the argument because you didn’t prepare well, but you can also lose rhetorically. And I’ll give you a rather humorous example of this. I did it a debate at an Episcopal high school outside of Philadelphia about 14 years ago and this was a liberal audience Episcopal you can imagine and I was debating a state house rep from Pennsylvania and honestly I destroyed the guy.
I absolutely crushed his arguments. I had researched what he was going to say. I knew what he was going to say. I was ready. And it wasn’t even close. But he recovered quite well at the end of the debate when he went to do a follow-up comment. I had the last statement in the debate. He wanted to make a final comment. And the debate moderator said, “No, you can’t do it.” And the state senator said, “Well, can I at least do smoke signals?” You know, and it got a big laugh.
And you know, it kind of it didn’t mean I lost, but it just goes to show you how little things in a debate can turn the exchange, and you have to be prepared for that. So, my salute to you for doing these debates. What do you What are you hearing from young pro-life leaders about the state of the culture today, where we’re at, what we need to be doing? I would just say even a lot of young just conservatives in general.
There’s especially young men there is a lot of angst around politics and this country and the future of this country and some of it is justified. But a lot of it they take way too far and they start to go to extreme people and extreme routes and they don’t yeah, they don’t really think through exactly the implications of their views or what they’re doing. And so what that’s looked like on the right is and on with conservatives is in a going to people like Nick Fuentes or Tucker Carlson and these people that are more extreme on the right.
But then when it comes to the pro-life movement and young men that are fiercely pro-life, it looks like them going to abolitionism and them becoming more abolitionists. And I think I think the abolitionists to their credit have done a good job of capturing the young men where they’re at. Now I don’t think that’s necessarily a good thing, but they have done that and they appeal to them in a certain way. And that that’s kind of where I’m feeling young men are at.
Now I think young women usually are at a totally different place and I mean if you look at the polls it looks like young men and young women are just going in opposite directions politically. But the young women that are conservative usually are more moderate and less extreme than their counterparts. Well, you brought up a topic that I have vowed to step away from for a while, and that is the whole abolition equal protection debate. So, thank you for going there.
But I do want to ask you about a piece that you’ve got that you’re going to be publishing very soon that we’re going to link to on this show entitled How Equal Protection Advocates Keep Losing Me. Do I have that title right?
Yeah, it’s how Equal Protection advocates have lost me. Okay. Well, that raises the question, how have they lost you, Micah? Give us some examples.
There’s basically three reasons why they’ve lost me, and it’s come down to different failures within I think just the conversations that I’ve seen surrounding this issue. And so the first one is I think a failure to present a compelling biblical or theological case. One if we’re going to separate equal protection real quick from abolitionists, right? Because there are some people that don’t identify as abolitionists but are equal protection. I haven’t actually seen, I don’t think, a single article or argument arguing biblically why we need equal protection.
Now, but on the abolition side, those that advocate for equal protection and that are abolitionists, their arguments are not very compelling to me at all. They’re biblical arguments.
Can you give me an idea of what arguments are not compelling to you?
Yeah. So, one like the Romans, 3 verse, I believe it’s Romans 3, where it talks about, you know, doing evil so good may come. And they try to apply this to a politician who is doesn’t have all the available options. They only have this terrible bill or this terrible bill and one does more evil than the other. And so the Romans verse I don’t think is talking about lawmakers in that position at all. Instead it’s actually I think talking about the person that is trying to justify evil doing their evil acts because of the good that may come.
Not that they would refrain from those evil apps acts if they like could, right? And so yeah, is it bad to is are these bills wrong? Yes, of course. But given the situation in which you’re choosing the lesser of two evils, you choose the lesser of two evils and you work your way to God’s perfect justice. And a lot of the verses that I’ve seen of abolitionists that talk about, you know, do justice and these things I would agree on, but the it almost begs the question them just citing these verses because the question is how do you do justice?
How do you achieve that?
And I would actually argue
Trying to prove
Exactly. And I would actually argue that abolitionism does less justice than incrementalism.
Yeah. I’m thinking of what Craig Ireland points out that the smashmouth incrementalist, which I would say is my position where we get all we can, we save all the children we can, and then we keep coming back till we get them all.
We’re in the position of not being able to end all evil. So, we do the best we can to save as many as we can. The abolitionist, or more accurately, the immediatist, is in the position of having the power to save some children, but he won’t do it. He’s willing to sacrifice, say, 70% of the children because he can’t get the other 30%. And I think they’ll be held accountable for that
100%. And that’s exactly what I argue in the article. And going back to Romans 3 and it and sometimes they’ll pair that with Isaiah chapter 10 about partiality and what have you, but those verses are not speaking about somebody trying to limit the evil done or lessen evil. They’re talking about the drivers, the originators who intend evil and create policies and create contexts where the poor are exploited. It’s not speaking to the person who’s powerless to get rid of all the evil.
So he does the best he can to mitigate it. Those verses, as you say, don’t apply.
And actually on the Isaiah 10 verse real quick, what I actually found is that the word when it talks about those who keep writing oppression, the writers who keep writing oppression, it’s talking about a repeated action. It’s talking about lawmakers that are repeatedly trying to do evil. Not lawmakers that are repeatedly trying to do good, which is what a lot of these pro-life lawmakers are trying to do. And so I just that verse does not seem to apply to me or apply in this debate at all.
Yeah, I quite agree with that. Micah, we’re going to take a very short break and when we come back, I want to ask you this question. Do you feel that equal protection advocates in general are failing to read the cultural room that we find ourselves in right now? And I’d like to get your response to that question. We’ll take that up right after this break.
Welcome back everyone. Great to have you. I’m here with my guest Micah Kungl who I consider to be one of the brightest upand cominging pro-life leaders. In fact, he is a pro-life leader. He’s not up and coming. He already is one and he’s one of the brightest minds out there. Micah, it’s great to have you. Before the break, I kind of teased you with a question. Do you think that equal protection advocates are at some level failing to read the cultural room that we find ourselves in today?
Yeah. Yeah. And that would be number three. My third point in the article. It’s a failure to show how these bills are practical and prudent. And yeah, I think there’s a there’s a there’s a major failure to read the cultural room. I mean, if you look around everywhere and unfortunately and this is this is sad, but unfortunately proifers are losing almost everywhere. There are there we do have wins here and there in different states. But we’re losing a whole lot and unfortunately what that means is that we need to take back this ground.
But we’re not going to do that if we’re pushing even more radical you know considered radical in our culture bills today. And there’s just I mean you look poll after poll, people are becoming less pro-life. There are more abortions that have been done. We almost lose in a state like Florida, which is a huge red state that we have. It almost gets enshrined in their constitution. They were a couple points away from that happening. And so I just don’t think I don’t see how it’s practical or prudent to even enact these bills.
Yeah. There’s certain cultural work you got to do. And this leads to something I’ve noticed. I don’t know if you’ve seen it. I have seen a misconstruction of the position you just articulated and the one that I happen to hold as well to be that we’re just afraid to advance anything that’s unpopular. That we’re afraid of what proaborts might think. But my position is not that I’m afraid of what proaborts think. I’ve been debating them publicly for 36 years. That has never scared me.
I’m worried about what these bills do right now to further marginalize partial pro-life voting blocks that we need to advance real legislation right now. And we need desperately to prevent these state ballot initiatives from continuing to take root in red states. I mean, right now we’re looking at all kinds of red states. Montana, Ohio, Kentucky, Missouri, recently Arizona, that have written abortion into their state constitutions. And if unless God intervenes, it’s going to happen again in Idaho and other states coming up, Virginia coming up in November.
We’re losing red states to voters who vote abortion into the state constitution. Now, my question for them is this. If we can’t even stop red states from voting abortion into their state constitutions, what makes us think that right now is the time to lead with bills that allow women to be prosecuted for murder that will be used against us to say to the public, “Hey, listen. Pro-lifers hate women. Want them incarcerated and by the way want them to die because they’re not going to give you the medical treatment you need if you have an ectopic pregnancy.
My concern is not popularity. I don’t care if I’m disliked. I’m used to that. What I care about is cultural sustainability. And like it or not, you cannot just pass a statute and expect it to hold up without having some measure of cultural foundation for it. You can pretend that’s not the case, but even biblically, think about the case of Josiah, arguably the most righteous king in all of Judah’s history. He banned child sacrifice with a royal decree. But here’s what happened.
Within a generation of his death, child sacrifice roared back because all the royal although the royal decree banned the practice, it didn’t change the hearts and motivations of the people that remained wicked. So the practice came roaring back. We can see this happen even in our current day in state or in countries like Australia that in Queensland for example they had a bill on the books that every abolitionist would love. This bill banned all abortion. It made it illegal. I mean no exceptions.
Everything we want. And yet the statute died standing up because no one would enforce it. The courts wouldn’t enforce it. Prosecutors wouldn’t bring cases. And so it died standing up. And this is what I fear. I’m not against abolition. In fact, you’re for it. I’m for it. I’m not even against prosecuting women for having abortions. I’m not like some pro-lifers that say we should never prosecute them. I say, “Oh, yes, we can and we ought to.” But there is prudence that come into play, prudence that comes into play when we talk about penalties.
And I think that’s where you’re landing here with your what I think was one of your points in your article. Do you think moving forward that we’re going to continue to see these bills fail or do you think there’s a chance they’re going to pass?
No, they’re going to continue to fail. Most of them like aren’t even getting voted on. And the Louisiana one the governor is or the governor vowed to veto it. So, yeah, that I don’t think any of these are going to are going to pass. I don’t think they’re viable at all. And Scott, to that point, too, the advocates themselves have a level of agreement here on cultural sustainability. Otherwise, why aren’t they pursuing something federal, right? Like, why even why even worry about the states?
Just go for the main one. Go for the federal government. Go for a federal abortion ban. They realize that that’s not practical.
In other words, they’re functioning incrementally.
Yes. And they can’t achieve that. And so they’re looking to do it with the states. And that’s something that I apply multiple times throughout the article is that I think truly if you were an abolitionist and if you weren’t taken by fear, right, as they put it, then you would pursue a federal abortion ban abolition all the way. But it’s not practical and it’s not going to happen in this cultural moment. And so that’s all what we’re arguing.
Yeah.
And so they agree, I think, on principle. They should actually be agreeing with us.
And I think here there’s something else here that strikes me as interesting. The way they tend to misconstrue our position. What do you say about that in your article?
There’s a failure to I think interact with our arguments. Well and a failure to even like a failure and this my second point in the article is a failure to refute the historical examples of social reforms.
And there’s just there’s not a deep interaction with it. They may have like a point here or there, but then as soon as you press them on that, they back away from it and say, “well, actually that wasn’t a great example.” Or, “Yeah, actually Wilbur Force, I wouldn’t have agreed with him doing that in this case.” So stunning.
Yeah, there’s just a failure to actually, I think, interact deeply with the arguments. And in debate, it’s called clash. And so when you have you have the initial arguments, right? You have your case and you have their case. But when the cases interact that start that that creates clash and I think as soon as the abolitionists start clashing with someone like you, Scott, they lose and their arguments fall apart.
What I have found is an utter ignorance of the history of social reform. And I’ve done a number of hostile interviews lately with people who don’t agree with me. Sometimes it’s twoon-one, sometimes it’s one-on-one. And I’ve been somewhat surprised, actually, shocked is more appropriate at their lack of knowledge about how social reform happens. Whether I’m talking about Lincoln or talking about Wilburforce or anybody, they don’t have an understanding of that. And I think that says something about why their case isn’t rooted in the real world we’re forced to live in as Christians where we aim to limit evil and promote the good as much as we can.
What else would you like to end with, Micah? We got about a minute. Do you have any final thoughts on your piece?
They’ve failed to provide a case. That’s basically what my piece is. Whether it’s biblical or theological, whether it’s historical or whether it’s being practical and prudent in this moment, they’ve lost me on those three reasons. And so for those three reasons, I’m still wanting to pursue an incremental approach. And I think that’s the only way to win. And if we look at the left, if we looked at how they have done what they have done and Carl Truman’s written a great book, the rise and triumph of the modern self.
Y
You can see that this has been a long time coming. This has been slow and incremental and it’s come through academia and Hollywood and it’s been pushed through different outlets way before any legislation hit any sort of floor.
Oh, I so we need to take a page out of their book and cuz they have been successful. Now I think they’ve jumped the gun when it comes to transgender issues and they are now losing people and now people are starting to wonder like huh actually this started a long time ago with contraception. Oh and they’re now starting to rethink these things and that’s the problem when you jump the gun on some of these
Social exactly. Hey we’re out of time for today. I wish we could go more. We’re out of time, but I want to thank you for writing the piece and for joining us today and look forward to having you on again soon. Micah, you’re doing good work.
Yeah, thanks Scott. I appreciate it.
We’ll see you soon, folks. Next edition coming up next week.