Election night
It was a painful night if you care about legislative attempts to protect human life. The result was a disaster. Democrats got major control of the U.S. Senate. They got a large majority in the House, and they won a majority of governorships and state houses. There’s really not a lot of good news.
A lot of reasons have been given for why this happened, and I’m not going to go into all of them. I think all of those reasons have merit. But I want to talk about the one that I think should most interest us as pro-lifers as we consider legislative strategies and how we engage a culture.
You may remember that in 2024, when Donald Trump was elected in a landslide, the number one issue he had going for him was the deportation of illegals who were committing violent crimes. He ran on that and hit the message over and over again, and the public said, yeah, he gets it. We don’t feel safe with our borders insecure and people able to come across without any kind of vetting or criminal background checks. When we go to the market for groceries or to the gas station, or we’re just going up to our apartment, we’re being accosted by people who don’t even belong here. That was a winning issue for Donald Trump.
However, there’s very interesting exit polling data on immigration. It says that 58 percent of the public, nearly 60 percent, voted against what they thought was an excess of the Trump administration’s immigration policies.
In other words, the public was willing to go with the president on deporting violent criminals and getting them out of here. Fine if you want to put them on planes and ship them to El Salvador or Venezuela or wherever. The public was on board with getting the violent people out. But the public wasn’t on board with slamming grandmothers to the ground who had lived here 25 years and committed no crime other than being here illegally. Now, I don’t think ICE agents targeted grandmothers with the intention of slamming them to the ground, but that was the perception of the voting public. In fact, the majority Hispanic coalition that put Trump over the top in 2024 turned against him this year. Sixty-some percent of those voters, almost 70 percent, voted for Democrats.
Why? Because they felt Trump overreached on what had been an area of strength for him. Consider that two years ago immigration was a winning issue for the GOP and a winning issue for Trump. In just two years it became a losing issue that cost them votes and was a big contributor to their losing control of Congress.
The administration outran its coverage
Here’s what happened. The administration outran its coverage. It overplayed its hand on immigration. It decided it was going to come in with loads of masked agents and deport people in what appeared to many to be a violent and excessive way.
Let me make my position clear. I don’t think it’s wrong to deport people who are here illegally. If you’re here illegally, I’d like you to leave the country and come back legally, and if you won’t do that, I think you should be deported. But I think the public looked at this and said, wait a minute, we voted to deport violent criminals. We didn’t vote to see grandmothers rounded up, families split apart, and children carted off to jails in Florida somewhere in the middle of a swamp. All of that worked against the GOP.
You can’t outrun the culture
So what lesson can we learn from this?
As a pro-lifer, you can pretend all day long that bringing the culture along with you doesn’t matter. Just push our bills and don’t even worry about where public sentiment is. Don’t worry about whether the culture supports a so-called equal protection bill that would allow women to be prosecuted for murder. Just go for it, get it passed wherever we can, and to heck with the fallout.
These midterm elections teach a very different lesson. If you pass a law but have not brought the culture along with you, if you have not properly educated people and persuaded voters that your position is true and rational to believe, they will turn on you when you overstep. That’s what happened here.
When I hear pro-lifers argue that we should just pass a bill that involves prosecuting women for murder, that we should pass these equal protection bills and not worry about the fallout because we’re doing God’s bidding, this is a move of God, and we don’t have to worry about whether we’re liked, I think they have one point I agree with. We don’t let whether we’re liked dictate what we do in articulating our pro-life defense or in passing laws. I agree with them to a point on that. But this isn’t an issue of whether we are liked and popular. It’s an issue of what the culture and the public will allow.
We are not a theocracy
Like it or not, we live in a constitutional republic. We are not a theocracy. We are not Israel, where God gives his law and says that’s the way it is, and if you deviate from it you could be executed. Under the Mosaic law, if you broke the Sabbath, you could be executed. If you talked back to your parents, you could be executed. For adultery and homosexual acts, the punishment was death. That’s the Mosaic law in a theocracy, where the nation is oriented toward being God’s chosen nation, a priesthood of holy people to him.
Is that where the United States, or any other Western democracy, is today? The answer is no. No nation is God’s chosen people today. There are nations that more or less line up with a biblical worldview and nations that more or less do not. That part’s true. But no nation is a theocracy governed directly by God. So we can’t take the civil and moral aspects of the Mosaic law and directly impose them on a constitutional republic, where believers are forced to live among unbelievers and where legislators who want to do the right thing have to do their job in an assembly that is not committed to God.
Those legislators need to maintain a faithful presence there. They need to do everything they can to limit evil and promote the good insofar as possible. But there’s no requirement that we throw prudence to the wind and say we don’t care what happens, we’re just going to do what we think is right, and we don’t care what the population thinks. As Trump found out on election day in these midterms, what the public thinks is a problem. If the culture is not with you on an issue, merely pushing your issue as far as you can will get a counter pushback that may vote you out of office.
Pro-lifers need to think about this. It does matter where the culture is, and we are going to have to be prudent and sequential in how we bring people along to the pro-life view. Do I want a culture where every child is protected in law and where abortion is treated at the criminal level like any other homicide? Yes. But you can’t take the principle and ram it through right now without any regard for where the culture actually is. The midterm elections teach the lesson: you’d better pay attention.
A glimmer of hope in Idaho
Having said that, there is a glimmer of hope. I know the election was a disaster, but look at the state of Idaho.
On election day, four states had abortion on the ballot, either reaffirming abortion rights already written into the state constitution or taking the step of writing them in. Idaho was the only one of the four that went the right way, and I want to talk about why, because I think there’s a model there.
Notice what was done in Idaho. The message the public got was not, hey, we pro-lifers want to jail women who have abortions and impose the death penalty if they’re found guilty by due process of law. That’s not what they led with. The other side led with the claim that pro-lifers hate women and want them to die, and that women are being denied necessary medical treatment because of pro-life laws like the one in Idaho. That message was resonating with a lot of voters. But pro-lifers were able to turn the course and pull a victory from what I was certain would be defeat.
Here’s how they did it. A large coalition of Mormons, Catholics and evangelicals got together, said we’re going to defeat this thing, and poured a ton of money into it. They ran ads, and one I saw was really effective. A young woman, maybe in her late twenties or early thirties, says she was suffering from an ectopic pregnancy. It was devastating to her, and she needed medical care to end that pregnancy because it was going to kill her. And she says she was able to get what she needed in terms of necessary medical care, even with the pro-life law. She had no trouble at all getting the care she needed, given that the child wasn’t going to live in the fallopian tube, and if they had not ended that pregnancy, the mother would have died too.
So this was not a question of abortion. It was a question of what you do when you’re presented with a medical situation where, if you don’t end the pregnancy, you’re going to lose two humans. That’s what happens when ectopic pregnancies aren’t managed. It becomes a very serious threat not to the mother’s health but to her very life. A pro-life doctor will act in such a way that he saves one life, even though the unintended but foreseen result is the death of the embryo. Morally, this young woman had good reason to pursue medical treatment that would end the pregnancy that threatened to kill her. And she says, looking at the camera, I had no trouble getting that.
That was very prudent, wise messaging to give to a skeptical culture that is being bombarded with the message that pro-lifers hate women and want them to die. Pro-lifers won in Idaho because they were smart about their messaging, and they were also smart about the coalitions they were willing to build.
Why I’ll work with people I disagree with
I’ve had pro-lifers tell me they won’t work with Catholics on abortion, or with Mormons, or with atheists. I’ve had people say, yes, I know there are groups out there like Secular Pro-Life, but I’m not going to work with them, because I’m a believer and I’m not going to be unequally yoked to any of these non-believing groups.
This is nonsense, and let me tell you why. Nobody is asking you to sign a profession of faith where you pretend you agree with everybody on key doctrinal issues. We most certainly don’t. I’m a Protestant, so I have doctrinal distinctives that differ from my Catholic friends. I certainly have them with Mormons. And of course I’m not an atheist, so at a very profound and fundamental level I differ from my atheist friends. But I’m willing to work with any like-minded people who are willing to oppose the intentional killing of innocent human beings.
You’re going to have to do that if you’re going to win in a constitutional republic. A constitutional republic doesn’t say find the people who agree with you on every theological point and work only with them. In a constitutional republic you’re going to work with a lot of people you differ with on theology, maybe even on the ultimate purpose and meaning of the world we live in. But you’re going to have to work with them nonetheless, because they share your view that we shouldn’t intentionally kill innocent human beings.
I’m happy to say that’s exactly what happened in Idaho. I had friends who were abolitionists and other friends who were not abolitionists working together with Catholics, Mormons and others to defeat this incredibly satanic ballot measure that would have written abortion rights into Idaho’s state constitution. Keep in mind Idaho is a deeply red state. Nevertheless, it came very close to writing abortion into its laws, because the message that pro-lifers hate women and want them to die resonates strongly. It took some prudent thinking on the part of pro-lifers to overcome that, and at least in Idaho they did. We were not successful in Virginia, Nevada and the other states, where we lost Missouri. But in Idaho I think we see a roadmap for prudent cooperation with a coalition of people we may disagree with on other things.
It always strikes me as funny. Suppose your own child fell into a swimming pool and was lying unconscious at the bottom, near drowning. A neighbor jumps over your fence and says, I’m a paramedic, I’ll save your kid. He pulls your child out of the pool, performs CPR, gets him breathing again and saves his life. Would you quiz that paramedic on his theology before you let him save your own child? If not, why do we quiz people about their theology when we’re talking about saving other people’s babies?
It seems to me we can agree to disagree on theology, and I’m not afraid to say I believe these other worldviews are wrong. I think my Catholic friends are wrong theologically. I think my Mormon friends are wrong, deeply wrong, theologically. And with my atheist friends, at the very foundational level, I don’t share their worldview. But that’s no excuse not to work with them to save children whose lives can be saved now. That’s what happened in Idaho, and I’m very glad to have seen it.
A viral post about a woman’s right to choose
We can wish it weren’t the case that we have to bring the culture along with us, but the reality is we do, and the GOP learned that lesson the hard way on election night. You can’t simply outrun the culture and push bills it isn’t willing to accept.
Now to that post. It went somewhat viral on social media just a couple of days ago. It’s an attempt to make Christians timid about their pro-life convictions. We see this every election cycle, and this is the latest entry. Here’s what it says:
Why has opposing a woman’s right to choose abortion become some kind of standard for measuring whether someone is a true follower of Christ?
There’s a lot to unpack there.
Where does that right come from?
Let’s start with the first thing. Notice the appeal to a right to an abortion. When anybody asserts a right to anything, whether to abortion, or to marry whoever they want, even someone of the same sex, or to marry several people and not just one, you are always correct to ask where that alleged right came from. A lot of Christians fail to ask, and it cedes to our opponents the intellectual ground and puts us on the defensive. So I always want to know where the right came from.
Here there’s an appeal to an alleged right to abortion, so my question for the person who posted this would be: where did that right come from?
Usually the response is that it came from the government: Roe v. Wade and other court cases. The problem is that the same court that creates a right to an abortion can do what? It can create a non-right to an abortion. That’s exactly what happened in Dobbs. The court said there is no right to an abortion in the U.S. Constitution, and as a result Dobbs struck down Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey, the federal court cases that wrote abortion law into our constitutional mindset.
So where does that right come from? They might say a woman has a fundamental right to an abortion. It’s always good to probe what they mean. A fundamental right is a right that is pre-political. She has it in virtue of her humanity. Government did not create it and does not mandate it. Government’s job is to recognize and protect that right, not to create one out of thin air.
As I’ve said before on the show, I don’t have a right to vote in the next British election, because I’m not British. But I do have a right not to be gunned down in the middle of Trafalgar Square if I visit London. The first is a statutory right that I would get only as a British citizen. The second, not to be gunned down in Trafalgar Square under Lord Nelson, is a natural right. My natural right not to be unjustly killed wherever I might be in the world is predicated on my humanity. It flows from my human nature. On the worldview that recognizes natural rights, rights spring from our human nature.
The poster doesn’t say where this right to an abortion comes from. If it comes from the government, she shouldn’t complain when government overturns it, because the same government that created a right to an abortion can abolish it. If she claims it’s a natural right she has in virtue of her humanity, then the uncomfortable question becomes: when do human beings begin to exist? If natural rights flow from our humanity, our natural rights begin when we begin to exist. That would mean the poster, on her own worldview, has a natural right to an abortion but no natural right to life if she’s in the womb. That creates a rather crazy scenario for thinking about so-called abortion rights.
Can a Christian be wrong about abortion?
Another thing. She asks how you can make whether someone supports abortion a test of whether they follow Jesus. In one sense, she’s right about this.
I think it’s possible for someone to be a Christian and have the wrong view on abortion. Suppose someone is a new believer. They’ve been a believer for a matter of weeks, or maybe months, and their worldview has not yet been brought fully into alignment with a biblical worldview. That happens all the time. My colleague Greg Koukl puts it well: Jesus first catches his fish, then he cleans them.
Here’s what Greg means. When you become a believer in Jesus, it’s because you underwent what is known as the new birth. God found you dead in sin, made you alive in Christ, and declared you righteous, not in virtue of anything you had intrinsically, but because his Son’s perfect righteousness was credited to your account. This is exactly what Paul talks about in Romans 4, speaking of Abraham. Was Abraham justified by his works? No. He was justified by faith. Abraham believed God, who justifies the ungodly, and it was reckoned, or credited, to him as righteousness. That’s the biblical doctrine of justification. We are declared righteous in virtue of what Jesus did in giving his life for ours and redeeming lost sinners.
Sanctification is also a doctrine, and it too is God’s work. It was God’s work to make us alive when we were dead spiritually, and it’s also his work to produce in us the fruit that shows we are truly justified. We become more and more Christlike in our behavior, our thought patterns, our attitudes and our actions toward others. Justification is instantaneous. It happens once, when we’re born again and made alive in Christ. Sanctification is gradual. It happens over time. So it’s entirely possible for someone to become a new believer and not yet align with a biblical worldview. That’s true.
No possible world
Now here’s what we can say, and ought to say. There is no possible world, and I don’t care what James Talarico says or anybody else, there is no possible world where a pro-abortion worldview aligns with a Christian worldview. You cannot get there.
Here’s why. Scripture is clear that all humans have value because they bear the image of God. Both the Old and New Testaments teach that. Scripture is also clear that because humans bear the image of God, the shedding of innocent blood, the intentional killing of an innocent human being, is forbidden. It’s wrong. Both Testaments teach that too. We know from the science of embryology that the unborn are human from fertilization. Therefore the same commands against shedding innocent blood apply to the unborn as image bearers, just as they apply to everyone else who bears God’s image.
So the idea that a Christian worldview can align with a pro-abortion worldview is false. But individual people who are born again, new Christians, may not yet align with that worldview.
So again, I’d want to know what the poster means. Is she saying you can be a dedicated Christ follower and always be someone who supports abortion? No, I don’t think so. But could there be an immature Christian, or a new Christian, whose worldview has yet to be aligned with a biblical one, and who therefore supports abortion? Yes, that could be true. But that’s very different from saying Christianity can be bent to align with a pro-abortion worldview. It cannot.
Stay hopeful
Folks, I want you to stay hopeful. This is not the end of the world just because we’ve had one bad election. People said that when Bill Clinton was elected and when Barack Obama was elected, and things changed. They’ll change again. Be faithful. Be a faithful witness to a biblical worldview wherever God has placed you. That’s your job. Go do it.
Episode Transcript
Hello everyone. What an incredibly bad two weeks it’s been, at least if you listen to the major pundits on the conservative side. And they’re of course referring to the election we just had. I’ll have a few words to say about that in just a moment. But before we get started, let me welcome you to the Case for Life program. We’re delighted to have you with us. If you have not had a chance yet to visit our primary sponsor, Life Training Institute, I hope you’ll do that. You can visit them at the links you see on the screen below. Alright, a couple of things we’re going to talk about today. Number one, we got to talk about the election. I know some of you don’t want to, but I think there’s a lesson there we need to learn and look at lest we forget and make the same mistake again. And then secondly, I want to read to you a widely popular meme that appeared on social media and we’ll dissect that and talk about it from a pro-life worldview.
Alright, first back to the election. Painful night if you care about the legislative attempts to protect human life. Disastrous result. Democrats got major control of the U.S. Senate. They got a large majority in the House and they won a majority of governorships and state houses. There’s really not a lot of good news and there’s been a lot of reasons given for why this happened and I’m not going to go into all of them. I think all of those reasons have merit but I want to talk about the one that I think most should interest us as pro-lifers as we consider legislative strategies and how we engage a culture. You may remember that in 2024 when Donald Trump was elected with a landslide, the number one issue he had going for him was the deportation of illegals who were committing violent crimes.
He ran on that and he hit that message over and over again and the public said, yeah, he gets it. We don’t feel safe with our borders being insecure and people able to come across the border without any kind of vetting, without any kind of criminal background checks. And now when we go to the market to get our groceries or the gas station to get gas, or we’re just going up to our apartment, we’re being accosted by people who don’t even belong here. And that was a winning issue for Donald Trump. However, there’s very interesting polling data, exit polling data, that goes to the issue of immigration. And here’s what that data says, that 68% of the public, let me back that up, 58% of the public, nearly 60% of the public, voted against what they thought was an excess of the Trump administration’s policies on immigration.
In other words, the public was willing to go with the president on deporting violent criminals on getting them out of here. Fine if you want to put them on planes and ship them to El Salvador or Venezuela wherever. The public was on board with getting the violent people out of here but the public wasn’t on board with slamming grandmothers to the ground who had lived here 25 years and committed no crime other than being here illegally. Now I don’t think ICE agents targeted grandmothers with intention of slamming them to the ground but that was the perception of the voting public. In fact, the majority Hispanic coalition that put Trump over the top in 2024 turned against him this year. In fact, 60 some percent of those people, almost 70 percent, voted for Democrats. Why is that?
Because they felt Trump overreached on what had been an area of strength for him. Now again, consider two years ago the issue of immigration was a winning issue for the GOP, winning issue for Trump, and in just two years it was a losing issue for the GOP and cost them votes and was a big contributor to them losing control of Congress. Now what happened was this.
The administration outran its coverage. In other words, what it did is it overplayed its hand on immigration. It decided it was going to come in with loads of masked agents and deport people in what appeared to many people to be violent and excessive. Now I don’t think it’s wrong to deport people who are here illegally. I want to make my position clear. If you’re here illegally, I’d like you to leave the country and come back legally. And if you won’t do that, I think you should be deported. However, I think the public looks at this and says, wait a minute, we voted to deport these violent criminals. We didn’t vote to see grandmothers rounded up and see families split apart and see children carted off to jails in Florida somewhere in the middle of a swamp and that all worked against the GOP. Now what is that lesson that we can learn from this?
Well when you’re a pro-lifer you can pretend all day long that bringing culture along with you doesn’t matter. We should just push our bills and not even worry about where public sentiment is. We don’t need to worry about whether the culture supports a so-called equal protection bill that would allow women to be prosecuted for murder. We should just go for it and get it passed wherever we can and you know what? To heck with the fallout. We’re not going to worry about that. Well, these midterm elections teach a very different lesson. If you pass a law but if not brought the culture along with you, you have not properly educated them, you’ve not persuaded voters that your position is true and rational to believe, they will turn on you when you overstep. And that’s what happened here. And I think when we hear pro-lifers argue, well, you know what, let’s just pass a bill that will involve prosecuting women for murder.
Let’s go ahead and pass these equal protection bills and not worry about the fallout because after all, we’re doing God’s bidding. This is a move of God and we don’t have to worry about whether we’re liked. Now I think they have one point I agree with. We don’t allow whether we are liked or not to dictate what we do in articulating our pro-life defense in passing laws. I agree with them to a point on that. But this isn’t an issue of whether we are liked and popular. This is an issue of what will the culture and the public allow. Now like it or not, we live in a constitutional republic. We are not a theocracy. We are not Israel where God just gives his law and says that’s the way it is. If you variate from this, you could be executed for that. For example, under the Mosaic law, you broke the Sabbath, you could be executed for that.
You talk back to your parents, you could be executed for that. You commit adultery, homosexual acts, the punishment was death, okay? That’s the Mosaic law and a theocracy where the nation is oriented toward being God’s chosen nation, a priesthood of holy people to him. The question today is, is that where the United States or any other western democracy is today? And the answer is no. No nation is God’s chosen people today. There are nations that more or less line up with a biblical worldview and nations that more or less do not. That part’s true. But no nation is a theocracy governed directly by God. So trying to take the mosaic law and say we’re going to take the civil and moral aspects of that law and just directly impose it on a constitutional republic where believers are forced to live among unbelievers and where legislators who want to do the right thing are forced to do their job in an assembly that is not committed to God.
Okay, they need to maintain a faithful presence there. They need to do everything they can to limit evil and promote the good insofar as possible. But there’s no requirement that we throw prudence to the wind and say we don’t care what happens, we’re just going to do what we think is right, and we don’t care what the population thinks. Well, the problem is, as Trump found out on election day in these midterms, it is a problem what the public thinks. And if the culture is not with you on an issue, merely pushing your issue as far as you can, is going get a counter pushback that may vote you out of office. And I think pro-lifers need to think about this. It does matter where the culture is and we are going to have to be prudent and sequential in how we bring them along to the pro-life view. Now, do I want a culture where every child is protected in law and where abortion is treated at the criminal level like every other aspect of just homicide?
Yes. But you can’t just take the principle and say we can ram that through right now without any regard to where the culture actually is. The midterm elections teach the lesson you better pay attention. Now having said that, there is a glimmer of hope. I know the election was a disaster but let me point you to a glimmer of hope. I want you to look at the state of Idaho. Now on election day four states had abortion on the ballot in terms of either reaffirming abortion rights being written into the state constitution or taking the step of writing them into the state constitution and Idaho was the only state out of four that went the right way. And I want to talk about why it went the right way because I think there’s a model there. Now notice what was done in Idaho. In Idaho, the messaging the public got was not, hey, we pro-lifers want to jail women who have abortions and we want to impose the death penalty if they’re found guilty by the due process of law.
That’s not what they led with. Now the other side led with pro-lifers hate women, want them to die, and women are being denied necessary medical treatment because of these pro-life laws like the one we have here in Idaho. That message was resonating with a lot of voters, but pro-lifers were able to turn course on that and pull a victory from what I was certain would be defeat, and they did it this way. A large coalition of Mormons, Catholics, and evangelicals got together and said we’re gonna defeat this thing and they poured a ton of money into it. They ran ads that talked about one ad I saw was really effective. It was a young girl. I’d say young girl, young woman. She might have been in her early 30s, late 20s, I don’t know, but she says you know I was suffering from an ectopic pregnancy. It was devastating to me and I needed medical care to end that pregnancy because it was going to kill me.
And I was able to get what I needed in terms of necessary medical care even with the pro-life law. I had no trouble at all having my pregnancy get the medical care it needed given the child wasn’t going to live being in the ectopic pregnancy tube the fallopian tube and if they had not ended that pregnancy the mother would have died too. So this was not a question of abortion. This was a question of what do you do when you’re presented with a medical situation where if you don’t end the pregnancy you’re going to lose two humans. That’s what happens when ectopic pregnancies can’t be managed. It becomes a very serious threat not to the mother’s health but to her very life. And if you’re a pro-life doctor you will act in such a way that you save one life even though the unintended but foreseen result is the death of the embryo.
So morally this young woman had a good reason to pursue medical treatment that would end the pregnancy that threatened to kill her. And she says, looking at the camera, I had no trouble getting that. All right, that was very prudent, wise messaging to give to a skeptical culture that is being bombarded with messaging saying pro-lifers hate women and want them to die. And pro-lifers won in Idaho because they were smart about their messaging and they were also smart about the coalitions they were willing to build. Now I’ve had pro-lifers say to me I’m not going to work with Catholics on abortion or I’m not going to work with Mormons or atheists. I’ve had people say to me yeah I know there’s groups out there like secular pro-life. I’m not going to work with them because I’m a believer and I’m not going to you know be unequally yoked to any of these non-believing groups.
Okay this is nonsense and let me tell you why. Nobody is asking you to sign a profession of faith where you pretend we agree with everybody on key doctrinal issues. We most certainly don’t. I’m a Protestant so therefore I have doctrinal distinctives that differ from my Catholic friends. I certainly have them that differ from Mormons and of course I’m not an atheist so at a very profound and fundamental level, I differ from my atheist friends. However, I’m willing to work with any like-minded people who are willing to oppose the intentional killing of innocent human beings. And I’ll tell you what, you’re going to have to do that if you’re going to win in a constitutional republic. A constitutional republic does not say find the people who agree with you on every theological point and work with them.
No, at a constitutional republic you’re going to work with a lot of people you differ with on theology, maybe even on ultimate purposes and ultimate meaning for the the world we live in, but you’re going to have to work with them nonetheless because they share your view that we shouldn’t intentionally kill innocent human beings. And I’m happy to say that in the state of Idaho that’s exactly what happened. I had friends who were abolitionists, other friends who were not abolitionists working together with Catholics and Mormons and others to defeat this incredibly satanic ballot measure that would have written abortion rights into Idaho’s state constitution. Now keep in mind Idaho is a deeply red state. Nevertheless it came very close to writing abortion into its state laws because the messaging that pro-lifers hate women and wants them to die resonates strongly and it took some prudent thinking on the behalf of pro-lifers to overcome that and I’m happy to say at least in Idaho they did that.
We were not successful doing that in Virginia, Nevada and other states where we lost Missouri. But at least there I think we see a roadmap for prudent cooperation with a coalition of people we may disagree with on other things. You know it always strikes me it’s funny If your own kid had fallen into a swimming pool and was near drowning and was lying on unconscious at the bottom of a swimming pool, if a neighbor jumped over your fence and said, hey, I’m a paramedic, I’ll save your kid. I can get him out and he pulls your kid out of the pool, performs CPR, gets your kid breathing again, saves your kid’s life. Would you quiz is that paramedic on his theology before you let him save your own child? If not, why do we quiz people about their theology when we’re talking about saving other people’s babies? It seems to me we can agree to disagree on the theological things and I’m not afraid to say I believe these other worldviews are wrong.
I think my Catholic friends are wrong theologically. I think my Mormon friends are wrong, deeply wrong theologically and my atheist friends at the very foundational level I don’t share your worldview, but that’s not an excuse to not work with them saving children whose lives can be saved now and that’s what happened in Idaho, and I’m very glad to have seen that. Alright, we’re gonna take a break. When we come back, I want to read you something that was all over the internet, at least all over social media, just a couple of days ago. I want to read it to you and walk you through it. It’s an attempt to make Christians timid on their pro-life convictions. We see this every election cycle and this is the latest entry. We’ll take a look at it right after this break.
Welcome back everyone. Now that we’ve had a moment to catch our breaths after this disastrous election, we learned a good lesson though, one that we need to keep in mind and that is you can’t simply outrun culture and push bills that they’re not willing to accept. We can wish it weren’t the case that we had to bring culture along with us but the reality is we do and the GOP learned that lesson the hard way on election night recently. All right before the break I mentioned something I saw on social media that has gone somewhat viral. I’m going to read it to you. What the meme says. Why has opposing a woman’s right to choose abortion become some kind of standard for measuring her willingness to follow Christ? Okay, a lot of stuff there to unpack. Let’s start with the first one.
Notice the appeal to a right to an abortion. When anybody asserts a right to anything. Abortion, the right to marry whoever they want even if it’s someone of the same gender or marry several people not just one whatever they assert. When they make a rights claim you are always correct to ask where did that alleged right come from and this is something a lot of Christians fail to do and it cedes to our opponents the intellectual ground that puts us on the defensive. So I always want to know where did this right come from? Now in this case there’s an appeal to an alleged right to abortion. So my question for the person who posted this meme would be this. Where did that right to an abortion come from? Now usually the response is well it came from the government.
Roe v. Wade, you know, in other court cases. All right. The problem with that is this, the same court that creates a right to an abortion can do what? Create a non-right to an abortion, right? And that’s exactly what happened in Dobbs. The court said, look, there is no right to an abortion in the U.S. Constitution. And as a result, Dobbs struck down Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood vs. Casey, the federal court cases that wrote abortion law into our constitutional mindsets. All right, so I want to know where does that right come from? Now they might say, well a woman has a fundamental right to an abortion. Okay, that means this, and it’s always good to probe what they mean by this. That means the woman has a right that is pre-political, and by that we mean this.
She has a right in virtue of her humanity that government did not create and government does not mandate. Government’s job is to recognize and protect that right, not create one out of thin air. So for example, as I’ve said before on this show, I don’t have a right to vote in the next British election because I’m not British. I do have a right not to be gunned down the middle of Trafalgar Square if I visit London. Now the first right is a statutory right that I get only in virtue of being a British citizen. But the second right, not to be gunned down in the middle of Trafalgar Square under Lord Nelson there, has to do with my natural right and that natural right not to be unjustly killed wherever I might be in the world is predicated upon my humanity. It flows from my human nature.
Rights spring from our human nature on the on the worldview that recognizes natural rights. Now what this poster is not doing is saying where this right to an abortion comes from. If it comes from the government, she shouldn’t be complaining if government overturns that right because the same government that created a right to an abortion can abolish it. Secondly, if she claims it’s a natural right in virtue of her humanity, then the uncomfortable question becomes, wait a minute, when do human beings begin to exist? Because if natural rights flow from our humanity, our natural rights begin when we begin to exist. Which would mean this poster here on her own worldview has a natural right to an abortion but not a natural right to life if she’s in the womb. And that, of course, creates a rather crazy scenario for thinking about so-called abortion rights.
All right, another thing about this, she says that how can you make whether or not you support abortion a test of whether or not you follow Jesus? Okay, in one sense, she’s right about this. And I’ll just read you her exact words here. If I can get my phone to cooperate. I can’t so I’m gonna have to go with the summary I gave a moment ago. But here’s the thing, here’s where the poster is correct.
I think it’s possible for someone to be a Christian and have the wrong view when it comes to abortion. For example, suppose someone’s a new believer, they’ve only been a believer maybe a matter of weeks or maybe even months and their worldview has not been brought fully into alignment with a biblical worldview. Happens all the time. My colleague Greg Koukl puts it well. Jesus first catches his fish, then he cleans them. And here’s what my friend Greg Koukl means. When you become a believer in Jesus, that happens because you underwent what is known as the new birth. God found you dead in sin, made you alive in Christ, and declared you righteous, not in virtue of what you had intrinsically, but on the fact that his Son’s perfect righteousness was credited to your account.
This is exactly what Paul talks about in Romans chapter 4, speaking of Abraham. He says, Was Abraham justified by his works? No. He was justified by faith. Abraham believed in God, who justifies the ungodly, Paul says, and it was reckoned to him or credited to him as righteousness. And that’s the biblical doctrine of justification. We are declared righteous in virtue of what Jesus did in giving his life for ours and redeeming lost sinners.
Sanctification is also a doctrine, and that too is God’s work. It was God’s work to make us alive when we were dead spiritually. It’s also his work in producing in us fruit that shows we are truly justified. We become more and more Christ-like in our behaviors, thought patterns, attitudes, and our actions toward others. However, justification is instantaneous. Happens one time when we’re born again and made alive in Christ.
Sanctification is gradual. It happens over time. So it’s entirely possible for someone to become a new believer and not yet align with a biblical worldview. That’s true. Now here’s what we can say and ought to say. There is no possible world, I don’t care what James Talarico says or anybody else, there is no possible world where a pro-abortion worldview aligns with a Christian worldview. You cannot get there and here’s why. Scripture is clear that all humans have value because they bear the image of God. Both Old and New Testaments teach that. It’s also clear that because humans bear the image of God, the shedding of innocent blood, the intentional killing of an innocent human being is forbidden. It’s wrong. Old and New Testaments teach that. We know from the science of embryology the unborn are human from fertilization. Therefore, the same commands against the shedding of innocent blood apply to the unborn as image bearers as they apply to everyone else who’s an image bearer.
So the idea that a Christian worldview can align with a pro-abortion worldview is false but individual people who are born again and new Christians may not yet align with that worldview. So again I’d want to know what the poster means here. Is she saying that you can be a dedicated Christ follower and you will always be one who supports abortion? No, I don’t think so. But could it be that there’s either an immature Christian or a new Christian who has yet to have their worldview aligned with a biblical one and they therefore support abortion? Yeah, that could be true, but that’s very different than saying Christianity can be bent to align with a Christian or bent to align with a pro-abortion worldview. It cannot. Folks, listen, I want you to stay hopeful. This is not the end of the world just because we’ve had one bad election. People said that when Bill Clinton was elected, when Barack Obama was elected, and things changed.
They’ll change again. Be faithful. Be a faithful witness to a biblical worldview wherever God has placed you. That’s your job. Go do it.